Real issue driving bag bans is litter

Published: June 4, 2012 6:00 am ET

Related to this story

Topics In Print

Three years ago, there were only five cities in the United States with bans on single-use plastic carryout bags, and the industry was convinced that it was simply a California coastal issue that would eventually go away.

How wrong they were.

Today, 74 U.S. communities have bans on plastic bags, and Los Angeles — the nation’s second-largest city — is set to join them in four months once it completes a required environmental impact report.

What’s more, one-third of those bans are now outside of California, and three of the 14 largest cities in the U.S and five of the 29 largest, have plastic bag bans.

How did the issue get so out of control when the industry worked so diligently to defend plastic bags?

It’s simple. The industry never understood — and still doesn’t understand — that the real issue is that plastic bags are a very visible piece of litter.

Instead, it has focused on explaining that the manufacture of plastic bags has a lower overall environment impact than the manufacture of paper bags, that a ban will cost people jobs, and that many of the bans contain a hidden tax, i.e, a fee on paper bags.

None of those arguments — no matter how valid — create a recycling solution that solves the plastic bag litter problem.

“Plastic bags often become litter after being properly disposed,” said Mark Murray, executive director of Californians Against Waste. “They blow out of trash cans, garbage trucks and landfills. This is one instance where recycling doesn’t seem to be the answer.”

But even in the aftermath of the 13-1 vote by the Los Angeles City Council in late May to draft a plastic bag ban, the industry stubbornly stuck to the same arguments.

“We are ... disappointed by the council’s decision to effectively disregard the facts and impose a misguided policy to ban plastic and paper bags [as] bag bans have not been proven to reduce litter,” said Mark Daniels, chairman of the American Progressive Bag Alliance and vice president of sustainability for bag manufacturer Hilex Poly LLC.

“This ordinance also calls for a regressive, hidden tax [on paper bags] without voter approval,” said Daniels. “The city of Los Angeles [has] put in motion a misguided and onerous policy that threatens the jobs of ... nearly 2,000 statewide.”

Even longtime plastics industry consultant Allan Griff, in a letter to Plastics News, expressed disappointment that the industry responses to the L.A. decision focused on “money and jobs.”

But even Griff suggested that the industry needs to “stress the environmental advantages of the bags ... and point to the bag-tossers as litter-pigs whose habits should not deprive the law-abiding majority” of those advantanges.

The stark reality is that legislators don’t care about the environmental advantages of plastic bags. If the industry sticks to the same strategy, it will only help fulfill the prophesy one industry executive made three years ago that there won’t be any plastic carryout bags in California in 10 years.

And that reality might come sooner — and spread widely across the U.S.


Comments

Real issue driving bag bans is litter

Published: June 4, 2012 6:00 am ET

Post Your Comments


Back to story

Market Reports

Market Data Book - Rankings & Lists

A one-stop download of Plastic News' exclusive annual lists and processor rankings containing essential data including sales, employees, end markets, materials and more.
EXCLUSIVE EXCEL FEATURE: full mailing address details for available plant locations.

Learn more

Thermoformed Packaging 2014 Market Review & Outlook North America

This in-depth report provides analysis and discussions of economic and political conditions, market trends, legislative/regulatory activity impacting supply and demand, business opportunities and threats, materials pricing, manufacturing technology, as well as strategies being implemented by thermoformed packaging companies. In addition, there are reviews of 25 leading thermoformers in the packaging segment, assessing their growth initiatives and performance metrics over 10 years.

Learn more

Mold Making and Tooling Review and Outlook 2014 North America

This report provides in-depth analysis of the mold and toolmaking market for North America, including discussions of trends, opportunities, threats, the latest developments in production and labor and equipment trends impacting moldmakers.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

May 6, 2014 - May 8, 2014Plastics in Medical Devices 2014

May 12, 2014 - May 12, 2014Plastics News Brazil Pharma Summit

September 10, 2014 - September 12, 2014Plastics Caps & Closures 2014

February 3, 2015 - February 7, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

More Events