Dow loses second court battle over R&D tax credit

Mike Verespej

Published: September 11, 2012 6:00 am ET

Related to this story

Topics Materials, Public Policy, Suppliers

NEW YORK (Sept. 11, 1:30 p.m. ET) — A second court has ruled against Dow Chemical Co. in its effort to obtain a research and development tax credit.

Dow is seeking the credit for supplies it purchases to make finished goods, when research is being conducted at the same time.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York upheld Sept. 7 a previous ruling from the U.S. Tax Court that those supplies do not qualify for a R&D tax credit because they would have been purchased regardless of any research that might have been conducted.

The case stems from an Internal Revenue Service ruling that Union Carbide Corp. was not entitled to $8 million in R&D tax credits during the 1994 and 1995 tax years for supplies the company had purchased for production of goods in three separate instances where it also was conducting research projects at production plants in Hahnville, La.

UCC had argued it was entitled to the credit because the company improved the way existing products were made during the course of production. UCC was purchased by Dow Chemical in 2001.

“Affording a credit for the costs of supplies that the taxpayer would have incurred regardless of any qualified research it was conducting simply creates an unintended windfall,” said the three-judge panel in its 11-page decision.

“We agree with the Tax Court that the costs for which UCC seeks a research credit are ‘at best, indirect research costs excluded from the definition of [qualified research expenses] under section 1.41-2(b)(2) [of the Treasury Regulations].’”

“As the Commissioner argues, [UCC] was entitled to a credit for only those additional supplies that were used to perform the research [because the] raw materials used to make finished goods that would have been purchased regardless of whether UCC was engaged in qualified research.”

Section 41(d)(2)(C) of the U.S. tax code provides that when a taxpayer seeks a research credit related to its production process, the production process must be divided into two business components, one that relates to the process and another that relates to the product, noted the court.

“This indicates that Congress intended to allow taxpayers research credits for research performed to improve their production processes, but ... did not intend for all of the activities that were associated with the production process to be eligible for the research credit if the taxpayer was performing research only with respect to the process, not the product,” said the three-judge panel in its opinion.

“The commissioner’s interpretation is entirely consistent with the purpose of the research tax credit, which is to provide a credit for the cost that a taxpayer incurs in conducting qualified research that he would not otherwise incur,” said the court. “We agree.”

Judge Rosemary Pooler, in a concurring opinion, suggested “that Congress may well have intended to give a tax credit for those supplies which would have been purchased absent any qualified research.”

But if that was the intent of Congress, she added, “it failed to write the statute in such precise terms so as to preclude either the Commissioner’s regulations or his interpretations. Accordingly, I join the majority opinion.”

"Union Carbide Corp. … is disappointed by the decision [and] is now considering its options," said Dow in a statement. "The case raises important issues relating to the availability of the R&D tax credit for plant-related process research. Plant related process R&D plays a central role in helping manufacturers achieve cost and efficiency savings and the availability of the tax credit is important to encourage and enable manufacturers to make these substantial R&D investments. The financial impact of this case to the company is not significant."


Comments

Dow loses second court battle over R&D tax credit

Mike Verespej

Published: September 11, 2012 6:00 am ET

Post Your Comments


Back to story


More stories

Image

Asia to remain chemical giant but US shale will bring competition

July 23, 2014 1:00 pm ET

A new IHS Chemical report on global spending for chemical production predicts capacity additions will peak in 2014 at $120 billion and then will...    More

Image

DuPont quarterly sales drop, income rises

July 23, 2014 12:46 pm ET

DuPont Co.'s sales and net income experienced slight changes for the second quarter 2014, as operating earnings dropped to $1.17 per share in the...    More

OSHA probes alleged asthma link to Lear's Selma, Ala., plant

July 23, 2014 11:58 am ET

U.S. foam manufacturer Renosol Seating LLC is being investigated following allegations its workers are at risk of asthma from TDI exposure at its...    More

Image

Celanese to expand production in Brazil

July 23, 2014 11:15 am ET

Celanese Corp., the Irving, Texas-based chemicals and specialty materials company, has announced that it will expand its manufacturing capabilities...    More

Image

Plastics industry blasted for stance in green building debate

July 22, 2014 2:45 pm ET

The plastics industry has taken high-profile stance in the debate over green building standards. The result, today at least, is that it's getting some...    More

Market Reports

Injection Molders Market Report & Ranking 2014

This special package contains our 132-page 2014 Market Report on the Injection Molding segment and our exclusive 2014 RANKINGS database of 500+ Injection Molders for a discounted package price.

Learn more

Plastics Recycling Market Review & Outlook 2014

This special report from Plastics News examines the North American plastics recycling industry and provides insight into indicators that impact market viability, including Resin pricing trends for virgin and recycled market material and historical Resin production trends for post- consumer and industrial waste.

Learn more

Shale Gas Market - Analysis of North American Region

This report highlights the impact of shale-based natural gas on the North American plastics market and features an in-depth analysis of production trends in the United States during 2013 and a forecast for 2014 and beyond.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

September 10, 2014 - September 12, 2014Plastics Caps & Closures 2014

February 4, 2015 - February 6, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

More Events