Dreamliners and Volts share batteries, but safety regimes differ

By Meribah Knight

Published: January 28, 2013 12:40 pm ET
Updated: January 28, 2013 12:43 pm ET

Related to this story

Topics Automotive, Aerospace
Companies & Associations General Motors Co.

CHICAGO -- As Boeing Co. and federal regulators wrestle with the safety issues plaguing the launch of the Dreamliner 787 and its lithium-ion batteries, there are parallels with the experience of the auto industry but far more differences -- due largely to the divergent approaches of government safety regulators.

In both industries, the introduction of lithium-ion batteries – as opposed to the more common nickel-cadmium battery — was driven by the quest for fuel efficiency and potency, since lithium-ion batteries hold their charge far longer and operate at a higher voltage.

Problems cropped up early on in both industries.

Boeing's 787 troubles include a battery fire on the ground and an emergency landing due to smoke from the battery. On Thursday, the National Transportation Safety Board indicated it had made little progress in determining the cause of the fires and said investigators were still at an early stage in their probe.

In 2011, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration investigated the Chevrolet Volt plug-in hybrid after its lithium-ion battery pack caught fire during crash testing. Last year, Anaheim, Calif.-based Fisker Automotive had two incidents involving battery fires in its Fisker Karma hybrids: one while a customer was charging the car in a garage in May and the second in a parking lot in August.

But despite the common focus on safe transportation, the regulatory apparatus and approach in the two industries are strikingly different. As is common in airline manufacturing, Chicago-based Boeing Co. worked closely with the Federal Aviation Administration from the beginning to gain certification, creating safety standards for the new technology.

While certifying the 787, an airliner made largely of carbon fiber-composite materials in place of metal, the FAA developed 17 "special conditions." With such novel design and technologies the existing certification standards were not adequate, the agency said.

In a speech last May, FAA Administrator Michael Huerta praised the collaboration. "The FAA and Boeing developed a new way of working together," he said. Huerta defended the agency's approach in a speech Wednesday before the Aero Club of Washington: "Some have asked the question whether the FAA has the expertise needed to oversee the Dreamliner's cutting-edge technology. The answer is yes, we have the ability to establish rigorous safety standards and to make sure that aircraft meet them."

For auto manufacturers such as Ford Motor Co. or General Motors Co., by contrast, more safety standards are set by industry groups. There are roughly 70 federal safety regulations for auto manufacturers compared with hundreds for aircraft. Only after a car goes to market will the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration administer a one-size-fits-all crash test that ranks a vehicle on its five-star safety scale. (The weight provided by the batteries is one reason electric vehicles tend to score well.)

Both Ford and GM say they do more battery testing on their electric and hybrid vehicles than in fuel-based vehicles because of the battery's role as a keystone technology. "It has been remarkable the lack of real problems with hybrid vehicles," said Dennis Virag, president of Ann Arbor, Mich.-based Automotive Consulting Group Inc. "The industry has done a great job as far as technological development and implementation."

While the auto industry has been making vehicles with lithium-ion batteries for three years, (the Dreamliner was the first commercial plant to use the rechargeable lithium-ion battery), the government still is adapting to the technology. Jose Alberto Ucles, a spokesman for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, said that out of the roughly 70 safety regulations for motor vehicles, the agency has no new procedures specific to electric vehicles and that its efforts are a "work in progress."

In a speech in May at a symposium for electric vehicle safety in Washington, NHTSA Administrator David Strickland said the agency is "actively working" on conducting crash tests and lithium-ion battery research. He said the agency also has initiated a safety research program to identify risks and measure the safety performance of lithium-ion powered vehicles. Asked about details of the research, Ucles said it was too early to discuss specifics.

While Boeing spent more than a million hours testing the lithium-ion batteries, some still said the technology was rushed to market. "They are pushing the technology too far too fast," said Myron Stokes, an analyst for automotive and aerospace industry analysis site eMotionReports.com in Bloomfield Hills, Mich.

Others said the battery malfunction may be just a fluke. "I think the design is probably adequate," said Gordon Bethune, former chief executive officer of Continental Airlines. "My wild-ass guess is it's a bad bunch of batteries."

Initial concerns about the 787 were focused not on the battery but the aircraft's novel composite materials. The 787 is the first major airliner with composite materials that comprise more than half its weight. When the FAA added the 17 extra certification conditions, only one pertained to the lithium-ion battery.

In September 2011, the U.S. Government Accountability Office filed a report to Congress on the FAA's oversight of the safety of composite airplanes. GAO cited four key concerns, all centered on the composite materials used in the 787. There was no mention of battery concerns.


Dreamliners and Volts share batteries, but safety regimes differ

By Meribah Knight

Published: January 28, 2013 12:40 pm ET
Updated: January 28, 2013 12:43 pm ET

Post Your Comments

Back to story

More stories


New Hexcel plant will supply carbon fiber for Airbus A350 XWB

September 30, 2014 2:43 pm ET

Hexcel Corp. is investing $250 million on a new carbon fiber plant in France, with part of the production going into the future Airbus SAS A350 XWB.    More


Ohio molder Denbro Plastics moves to new location

September 29, 2014 6:17 pm ET

Logo products injection molder Denbro Plastics Co. has moved to another plant within Toledo, Ohio, to streamline production and improve efficiency.    More


Japan's parts makers face challenges as carmakers expand supply base

September 29, 2014 11:01 am ET

For all their size and success, Japanese auto suppliers that rocketed to global dominance on the coattails of their No. 1 customer, Toyota Motor Corp....    More


ZF, TRW combination creating a new player for autonomous autos

September 23, 2014 9:59 am ET

The era of autonomous vehicles is close at hand — and is already changing the auto industry in fundamental ways. The latest and biggest example?...    More


Delphi buying connector maker Antaya

September 22, 2014 2:25 pm ET

Delphi Automotive plc will buy Antaya Technologies Corp., a Rhode Island company that supplies wire harnesses and other technologies that connect with...    More

Market Reports

Plastics in Mexico - State of the Industry Report

This report analyzes the $20 million dollar plastics industry in Mexico including sales of machinery & equipment, resins and finished products.

Our industry analysis highlights macro industry trends and micro trends faced by companies that do business in Mexico. The report also provides key industry statistics and forecasts to anticipate future industry expansion.

Learn more

Plastics Caps & Closures Market Report

The annual recap of top trends and future outlook for the plastics caps & closures market features interviews with industry thought leaders and Bill Wood’s economic forecast of trends in growing end markets. You will also gain insight on trends in caps design, materials, machinery, molds & tooling and reviews of mergers & acquisitions.

Learn more

Injection Molders Market Report & Ranking 2014

This special package contains our 132-page 2014 Market Report on the Injection Molding segment and our exclusive 2014 RANKINGS database of 500+ Injection Molders for a discounted package price.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

January 14, 2015 - January 14, 2015Plastics in Automotive

February 4, 2015 - February 6, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

June 2, 2015 - June 3, 2015Plastics Financial Summit - Chicago 2015

September 16, 2015 - September 18, 2015Plastics Caps & Closures - September 2015

More Events