California appeals court rules in favor of 10-cent bag fee

By Gayle S. Putrich
Staff Reporter

Published: February 25, 2013 7:46 pm ET
Updated: February 25, 2013 7:49 pm ET

Related to this story

Topics Legal, Government & Legislation, Grocery bags

WASHINGTON -- The ban on plastic bags and the 10-cent fee for paper bags that came with it in the Los Angeles area is not considered a tax that requires voter approval, according to a ruling last week by a state appellate court.

The California Court of Appeal for the Second District ruled against plastic bag manufacturer Hilex Poly Co. LLC and a group of unincorporated Los Angeles County residents, saying that the fee can stand. The paper bag charge is not a tax and not in violations of California Proposition 26, wrote the judges in the 3-0 decision, "because the charge is payable to and retained by the retail store and is not remitted to the county."

But the bag battle is expected to continue, with Hilex Poly lawyers already planning an appeal to the state Supreme Court.

"We respectfully disagree with the court's ruling. We continue to believe that the 10-cent bag 'charge' is a violation of Proposition 26, which mandates that 'any levy, charge or exaction of any kind imposed by a local government' must be approved by local voters. We intend to seek Supreme Court review," said James Parrinello, of Nielsen Merksamer Parrinello Gross & Leoni LLP, in a statement.

Proposition 26 was approved by California voters in November 2010 and requires a two-third vote in both chambers of the state legislature for new statewide fees and taxes, and a two-thirds vote in local communities for the adoption of local fees and taxes. It also broadened the definition of a tax to include many fees but makes exception for "reasonable" fees to cover the cost of a product or service.

The suburban Los Angeles ban on plastic bags and establishment of fees for paper ones took effect in July 2011 for larger stores and January 2012 for smaller stores. Hilex Poly, a leading thin film manufacturer and recycling firm based in Hartsville, S.C., along with four California residents, have been battling the ordinance in court since October 2011.

Mark Murray, executive director of Californians Against Waste, says while it's their prerogative to move forward, he does not foresee any traction for continued battles against the plastic bag ban or the paper bag fee.

"The courts have now spoke twice," Murray said. "And local governments haven't been hesitating because of this pending decision. Cities and counties have continued to move forward [with plastic bag bans and fees] without skipping a beat."

Concern for cleaner oceans and waterways have been a major driver in the support behind the 65 county and municipal plastic bag ordinances that have been enacted since San Francisco first banned plastic bags in 2007.

Mark Daniels, senior vice president for sustainability and environmental policy at Hilex Poly, continues to contend that such bans and fee programs are not the answer.

"Bans and taxes on plastic bags will not help solve the litter problem. Plastic bags only make up a fraction of one percent of waste overall. The truth is plastic bags are a better option than reusable and paper bags – both of which have greater environmental impacts," he said in a statement issued Feb. 25. "Unfairly targeting plastic bags only makes it more expensive for families to shop."


California appeals court rules in favor of 10-cent bag fee

By Gayle S. Putrich
Staff Reporter

Published: February 25, 2013 7:46 pm ET
Updated: February 25, 2013 7:49 pm ET

Post Your Comments

Back to story

More stories


Choon's Design moves ahead with patent lawsuit against Rainbow Loom rivals

August 18, 2014 1:43 pm ET

Wixom, Mich.-based Choon's Design LLC, makers of the popular Rainbow Loom bracelet making kit, will proceed with patent infringement lawsuits against ...    More


Dow Corning lauds China for crackdown on counterfeiting

August 14, 2014 11:27 am ET

Dow Corning Corp. officials say they appreciate efforts of the Chinese officials in their effort to crack down on counterfeit trafficking.    More

Market Reports

Thermoformed Packaging 2014 Market Review & Outlook North America

This in-depth report analyzes economic and market trends, legislative/regulatory activity impacting supply and demand, business opportunities and threats, materials pricing, manufacturing technology, as well as growth strategies being implemented by thermoformed packaging companies.

Learn more

Pipe, Profile & Tubing Extrusion in North America 2014

U.S. demand for extruded plastics is expected to grow by 3 percent in 2014, with PVC remaining the largest segment.

Plastic pipe will post the strongest gains through 2018, continuing to take market share from competing materials in a range of markets.

Our latest market report provides in-depth analysis of current trends and their financial impact on the pipe, profile and tubing extrusion industry in North America.

Learn more

2014 Injection Molding Industry Report


In the wake of the economic turbulence earlier in this decade, molders today find themselves in much better shape. Molders are gaining a competitive advantage by investing in people, equipment and seeking inroads into new markets on a global scale.

Growth in the injection molding industry is going to be driven by low financing costs and a continued move to reshore some business.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

September 10, 2014 - September 12, 2014Plastics Caps & Closures 2014

January 14, 2015 - January 14, 2015Plastics in Automotive

February 4, 2015 - February 6, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

More Events