TSCA overhaul stalls over debate about language

By Gayle S. Putrich
Staff Reporter

Published: August 2, 2013 2:33 pm ET
Updated: August 2, 2013 2:36 pm ET

Related to this story

Topics Public Policy, Government & Legislation
Companies & Associations Dow Chemical Co., DuPont Co.

WASHINGTON — In the few months since it was introduced, a bill to update 1970s-era chemical regulations has gone from being hailed as a bipartisan compromise sure to pass to a contentious regulatory measure with a very uncertain future.

In a July 31 marathon hearing, Sen. Barbara Boxer, chairwoman of the Environment and Public Works Committee, made it clear to the bill’s co-author, 19 witnesses and a packed room that the Chemical Safety Improvement Act of 2013 (CSIA-S1009) would not make it to the Senate floor without extensive revision.

“If we don’t fix these problems, we’re not going to have a bill,” said Boxer, D-Calif.

Boxer and others fear language in the bill could pre-empt state authority to regulate or restrict chemicals used or sold within their borders once the Environmental Protection Agency acts on those substances. Boxer and other Californians fear the language could undermine rigorous chemical and environmental laws on the state’s books, such as Proposition 65.

At the same time, Boxer also said once sufficient changes are made to CSIA, she wants to put the bill on a fast track to enactment.

The compromise measure unveiled in May by co-authors Sen. David Vitter, R-La., and the late Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., after more than a decade of disagreements would require safety testing of all chemicals on the market as well as new chemicals, and would grant the EPA authority to phase out or ban chemicals deemed harmful, from flame retardants to building materials to bisphenol A.

It would be the first overhaul of the much-maligned Toxic Substance Control Act (TSCA) since its 1976 enactment, which both sides of the aisle and even those outside the Beltway agree has mostly been a failure. The Vitter-Lautenberg deal had drawn support from the chemical industry — including the American Chemistry Council and the Society of the Plastics Industry Inc. — as well as smaller states that don’t have the capacity to extensively regulate chemicals on their own. But state attorneys general and environmental groups oppose the bill, saying it would usurp state laws now in place and working well that were passed in the vacuum left by decades of federal inaction.

Robin Greenwald, a lawyer with Weitz and Luxenberg, testified the bill would take “unprecedented” action in pre-empting state laws. Thomas McGarity, an expert at the Center for Progressive Reform, told the committee that one of the few provisions in TSCA that actually works is the provision that keeps the chemical law from preempting state laws.

“I wrote a book about pre-emption and I didn’t have to mention TSCA,” he said. McGarity called the proposed bill “an intrusive interjection into the day-to-day administration of justice in our courts” and warned that “as written, [CSIA] may make a bad situation worse.”

“But it can be fixed,” he said.

Others disputed such analysis of the proposed law. Mark Duvall, a Beveridge and Diamond lawyer with extensive experience with TSCA, testified that the concerned attorneys general are “wrong in almost all instances” and said CSIA “significantly expands the roles of states in EPA’s decision-making under TSCA.” Duvall also pointed out that some chemicals singled out as items of concern by those opposed to CSIA, such as phthalates, are subject instead to the Consumer Products Safety Act and are not actually regulated under TSCA, nor would they fall under CSIA if it became law.

Vitter said repeatedly he was already at work with Sen. Tom Udall, D-N.M., on an amendment to the bill that would make “crystal clear” that the federal law would not neuter state laws as well as make other clarifications based on “very legitimate suggestions for improvement.”

“[Lautenberg and I] in no way intended to remove authority of states or violate existing tort law,” Vitter said. “We thought that was clear in our language, but Sen. Udall and I are going to make it crystal clear in our managers’ amendment.” Boxer jumped in to say the Vitter-Udall amendment must also meet her approval and that she will be working on it with them.

Boxer also repeatedly asked each panel of witnesses to pledge their willingness to work with senators to adjust the bill, sometimes assigning “homework” to witnesses, asking them to circle and annotate parts of the measure they do and do not like for the committee.

“I have been a regulator and I have been regulated and I must say that it doesn’t matter where you sit, TSCA is a very difficult statute to implement,” said Linda Fisher, chief sustainability officer for DuPont Co. and a former EPA official.

The patchwork of state-by-state regulations enacted as TSCA became increasingly outdated has made it difficult for businesses large and small to sort through, Fisher said. The new bill would grant EPA the authority to systematically assess chemicals, but the agency should not be overburdened with multiple frameworks for doing so, she said.


Comments

TSCA overhaul stalls over debate about language

By Gayle S. Putrich
Staff Reporter

Published: August 2, 2013 2:33 pm ET
Updated: August 2, 2013 2:36 pm ET

Post Your Comments


Back to story


More stories

With European Parliament vote looming, official urges bag restriction

April 16, 2014 9:56 am ET

Janez Potocnik, Europe's commissioner for the environment, told the European Parliament April 15 that plastic shopping bags are a “highly...    More

Shell Chemical to host public meetings to discuss plans in Pennsylvania

April 15, 2014 3:27 pm ET

Shell Chemical LP will host two public meetings on April 16 to discuss the possibility of building a major petrochemicals plant in the Pittsburgh...    More

Shintech in early stages of planning ethylene feedstock plant in Louisiana

April 15, 2014 3:22 pm ET

Shintech Inc. has filed an air permit with the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality that would allow for the construction of a new unit with ...    More

Plastics recycling rates in Michigan will go up, if new initiative works

April 14, 2014 4:15 pm ET

Clean Tech, a unit of Plastipak Packaging Inc., expects to recycle about 6 billion plastic bottles this year and has an eye on 10 billion plastic...    More

No action yet, but opposition still brewing to medical device tax

April 11, 2014 1:29 pm ET

Indiana politicians are stepping up their game in attempts to get the much-maligned medical device tax repealed.    More

Market Reports

Thermoformed Packaging 2014 Market Review & Outlook North America

This in-depth report provides analysis and discussions of economic and political conditions, market trends, legislative/regulatory activity impacting supply and demand, business opportunities and threats, materials pricing, manufacturing technology, as well as strategies being implemented by thermoformed packaging companies. In addition, there are reviews of 25 leading thermoformers in the packaging segment, assessing their growth initiatives and performance metrics over 10 years.

Learn more

Automotive Market Review and Outlook 2014 The Americas

This 75-page report features in-depth analysis of the automotive industry for the Americas. It includes discussions of market trends, legislative/regulatory activity impacting production and threats as well as design strategies being implemented by the major automakers. Detailed charts and data tables outline North American automotive production over the last five years.

Learn more

Plastics Building & Construction Market Review and Outlook 2014 with MS Excel chart data

This report provides in-depth analysis of the plastic building and construction market for North America, including discussions of trends, opportunities, threats and the latest developments in construction trends that impact plastics processors.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

May 6, 2014 - May 8, 2014Plastics in Medical Devices 2014

May 12, 2014 - May 12, 2014Plastics News Brazil Pharma Summit

September 10, 2014 - September 12, 2014Plastics Caps & Closures 2014

February 3, 2015 - February 7, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

More Events