Formosa defends $22.5M settlement in PVC pipe case

By Catherine Kavanaugh
Staff Reporter

Published: December 17, 2013 11:46 am ET
Updated: December 17, 2013 11:49 am ET

Related to this story

Topics Legal, Construction, Extrusion, Pipe/Profile/Tubing

Attorneys for Formosa Plastics Co. USA (FPC-USA) say PVC pipe maker JM Eagle has no legal standing to object to the proposed $22.5 million settlement Formosa reached with 45 government entities in a whistle-blower lawsuit.

U.S. District Judge George H. Wu is scheduled to rule Dec. 19 on the settlement between FPC-USA, the former parent company of JM Eagle, and the states, cities and water districts that bought questionable pipe for water and sewer systems from 1996-2006.

The settlement was reached with help from a mediator just before the start of a 7-week trial where JM and FPC-USA were co-defendants. The judge granted Formosa a conditional dismissal on Sept. 13 and the trial went forward against JM Eagle.

On Nov. 14, jurors found JM Eagle guilty of violating the False Claims Act by manufacturing pipes of questionable quality, representing that the pipe conformed to industry standards, and then selling it for municipal water and sewer systems. JM Eagle plans to appeal.

In the meantime, JM Eagle attorneys are calling the proposed FPC-USA settlement “paltry” compared to the plaintiffs’ statements that the pipe maker could owe billions of dollars of damages. On Dec. 6, they asked the federal judge to reject the proposal or delay approval.

Formosa attorneys question the timing of JM Eagle’s attempt to block or postpone the settlement in a legal brief they filed Dec. 13. They note that JM Eagle did not object when the court ordered the parties to participate in mediation or when the settlement was disclosed to the court or when Formosa was given a conditional dismissal from the first phase of the trial.

“Having decisively lost the phase one trial, J-M now objects to the settlement and seeks to hold FPC-USA hostage in this action,” says the brief submitted by Formosa’s legal team with Holland & Knight LLP.

The brief goes on to say JM Eagle has no standing to challenge the settlement because it doesn’t cause the pipe maker any kind of legal prejudice or strip the defendant of any legal right, claim or defense.

The settlement was achieved during lengthy negotiations mediated by retired Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward A. Infante. FPC-USA and the attorney generals of Nevada, New Mexico and Virginia and dozens of local officials have agreed to it. The settlement awaits the judge’s ruling as to whether it is fair, reasonable and adequate.

Damages owed by JM Eagle to the plaintiffs are to be determined in a second phase of the trial.

“J-M may not look forward to ‘going it alone’ in this action, particularly in the aftermath of its recent and decisive trial loss; but J-M has no basis to prevent FPC-USA from settling the FCA claims against it,” Formosa’s Dec. 13 brief says.

Formosa officials admit no liability in the proposed settlement and agree to settle to avoid further legal expenses in the case, which dates back to 2006.

JM Eagle officials have vowed to appeal in a recent letter to customers reminding them about a 50-year warranty on their pipes. The appeal will be based on evidence not allowed during trial, including test results showing the company’s pipe passed tests commissioned by the plaintiffs and federal government, as well as the wording of a jury form.

JM Eagle attorneys say the jury form was phrased in such a way that the company was liable even if only a single piece of pipe was non-compliant out of billions of feet of pipe manufactured in the 10-year period.

JM Eagle officials also say real-life evidence shows the pipe in the ground performs well.


Comments

Formosa defends $22.5M settlement in PVC pipe case

By Catherine Kavanaugh
Staff Reporter

Published: December 17, 2013 11:46 am ET
Updated: December 17, 2013 11:49 am ET

Post Your Comments


Back to story


More stories

Image

Judge limits scope of jury verdict against JM Eagle

December 19, 2014 2:30 pm ET

A federal judge in Los Angeles said Dec. 18 that last year's jury verdict issued against J-M Manufacturing Co. — now JM Eagle — for...    More

Image

Soy-based foam improves window performance, sustainability

December 18, 2014 12:51 pm ET

Launched in April 2013, Madison, Wis.-based WFI Global LLC is making a name in the fenestration market with what it says is a distinct product...    More

Image

Pent-up demand fueling extrusion machinery market

December 9, 2014 1:10 pm ET

These are good times for machinery companies that serve flexible packaging — big-dollar items like blown and cast film equipment, and sheet...    More

Image

Brazilian-owned buyer to reopen Ohio films plant

December 8, 2014 4:08 pm ET

UPDATED — The 70 workers at Dow Chemical Co.’s polyolefin films plant in Findlay, Ohio, have received an early Christmas present —...    More

Image

Clear Lam adds co-packaging capabilities

December 8, 2014 2:22 pm ET

Clear Lam Packaging Inc. is investing $2 million to create a co-packing facility and innovation center at the company's Elk Grove Village, Ill., manuf...    More

Market Reports

Flexible Packaging Trends in North America

Our latest RESEARCH report examines trends in FLEXIBLE PACKAGING impacting the North American market including a review of economic conditions, key drivers of growth, materials pricing, M&A activity, sustainability challenges and the outlook for 2015.

Learn more

Plastics in Brazil - State of the Industry Report

This in-depth report examines the Brazilian plastics industry from a historical and geographical context. Our analysts provide insight on economic trends and forecasts, growing manufacturing sectors that utilize plastics, private investment opportunities, market environment challenges, and innovations in R&D.

Data tables and charts on producer prices, trade, plastics production and end market indicators is also included.

Learn more

Plastics Recycling Trends in North America

This report is a review and analysis of the North American Plastics Recycling Industry, including key trends and statistics based on 2013 performance. We examine market environment factors, regulatory issues, industry challenges, key drivers and emerging trends in post-consumer and post-industrial recycling.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

January 14, 2015 - January 14, 2015Plastics in Automotive

February 4, 2015 - February 6, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

June 2, 2015 - June 3, 2015Plastics Financial Summit - Chicago 2015

September 16, 2015 - September 18, 2015Plastics Caps & Closures - September 2015

October 27, 2015 - October 29, 2015Plastics Financial Summit - New York - 2015

More Events