JM Eagle slaps law firm with libel complaint

By Catherine Kavanaugh
Staff Reporter

Published: February 25, 2014 1:32 pm ET
Updated: February 25, 2014 1:37 pm ET

Related to this story

Topics Construction, Pipe/Profile/Tubing, Extrusion, Legal
Companies & Associations J-M Manufacturing Co. Inc.

JM Eagle is very litigious these days.

The same day it filed a lawsuit in New Jersey against a whistle blower and the law firm representing him for allegedly stealing documents, the largest PVC pipe extruder in North America accused the same law firm of libel in California for a news release it issued last year.

J-M Manufacturing Co., the former name of JM Eagle, is listed as the plaintiff in both lawsuits filed Feb. 21 against Phillips & Cohen, LLP, which has offices in San Francisco and Washington, D.C.

The latest legal actions in the case, which dates back to 2006, come three months after a federal jury in California found J-M violated the False Claims Act by selling PVC pipe of questionable quality to government entities for water and sewage systems.

Monetary damages will be determined in a second phase of the trial.

In an email to Plastics News, Phillips & Cohen said: “J-M is attacking our firm to retaliate for our victory against them at trial. We are confident the courts will see these lawsuits for what they are: a futile attempt to intimidate us as we move into the next phase of the whistleblower litigation. We strongly believe J-M’s lawsuits against Phillips & Cohen are frivolous and look forward to demonstrating that in court.

“J-M made the same accusations about stealing documents to the federal judge in the whistleblower case, and the judge repeatedly found that the firm and our client did nothing improper in providing copies of J-M’s documents to the government.”

Phillips & Cohen also represents 45 water districts, cities and states and a dozen interveners that bought the J-M pipes from 1996-2006. The law firm issued the controversial news release on Nov. 15, after the jury verdict came back in its favor.

J-M alleges the news release was false and defamatory because it referred to the company’s pipes as “faulty,” “substandard,” “weak” and “shoddy.”

The libel lawsuit says the jury verdict only applies to five public utilities that were selected as “exemplar plaintiffs” and no evidence was presented that anyone received and paid for J-M pipe that didn’t meet industry standards.

“In sum, the jury’s ‘uniform compliance’ finding established that, like all product manufacturers, J-M had not achieved absolute manufacturing perfection, but it did not establish that J-M sold substandard or defective pipe to any qui tam plaintiff or any other identified J-M customer,” the libel lawsuit says.

The Phillips & Cohen news release issued to media outlets across the country was not a fair or accurate portrayal of the trial proceedings, according to the libel lawsuit.

“The press release’s gross misrepresentations captured neither the sting nor the gist of the jury’s findings,’ it continues. “Contrary to P&C’s press release, the trial did not determine whether J-M’s pipe was substandard or defective, which it is not.”

J-M also has raised issues about jury instructions and what it says were distortions of industry pipe standards that contributed to a “miscarriage of justice.” J-M is asking for a new trial and a court hearing is scheduled for March 13 in California on the request.

In the New Jersey lawsuit, J-M is suing Phillips & Cohen and the whistle blower for the alleged theft of hundreds of confidential documents used to build a False Claims Act case against the Los Angeles-based company.

This nine-count lawsuit says the whistle blower, John Hendrix, a product assurance engineer fired from J-M’s plant in New Jersey, breached a contract he signed in June 2002 not to divulge financial information, trade secrets, proprietary information and confidential data belonging to or relating to the company.

The 23-page lawsuit says Hendrix violated the so-called “employee secrecy agreement” at the direction of the law firm from August through November 2005. That’s when Hendrix allegedly searched J-M’s AS400 database for protected information, emailed information, smuggled out paperwork to make copies then returned it, recorded conversations, wrote “set-up emails” with colleagues, attempted to obtain product test results from outside laboratories, and solicited a kickback from a customer.

J-M says Hendrix was fired after the alleged kickback incident. However, Hendrix says he was terminated for confronting management about quality control issues.

Hendrix contends JM employees cut corners to meet production quotas and much of the pipe sold in the 10-year period didn’t meet industry standards and has shorter life spans than promised.

Hendrix did not testify during the seven-week trial but other witnesses said plant managers removed “reject” tags from pipe identified as substandard and shipped it to customers. If anyone complained, witnesses said they were told to blame improper installation or factors other than manufacturing defects.

The jury saw more than 300 JM documents during the trial before U.S. District Judge George Wu that ended in November.

A transcript of court proceedings from July 18, 2013, indicates Judge Wu considered the employee secrecy agreement signed by Hendrix, who is also referred to as a “relator” in the original whistle blower case.

The judge says in the transcript, “… if the relater even with the advice of counsel obtains evidence which would not be otherwise privileged or anything but simply is a violation of let’s say a confidentiality agreement or something of that sort, I would agree with the plaintiffs’ position in this case that a confidentiality agreement cannot trump the production of relevant information so long as the relevant information is not otherwise obtained illegally or does not otherwise overlap with privileged documents or something of that sort.”

The lawsuit also alleges a breach of fiduciary duty, computer-related offenses, and trespassing against the whistle blower as well as conspiracy and racketeering against all defendants.

In addition, the lawsuit alleges aiding and abetting against 1-50 John/Jane Does who recruited customers of JM products to be plaintiffs in the False Claims Act trial before Judge Wu in Los Angeles. The yet-to-be-named defendants also are accused of interference with contractual rights and prospective economic advantage.

As a result of all the allegations, JM says it “suffered great financial harm” due to the loss of business from existing and prospective customers who removed the company’s pipes from their approved-products lists.

JM is seeking compensatory, punitive and exemplary damages, recovery of legal fees and any other relief the court proper.

In a related matter in January, Judge Wu approved a $22.5 million settlement between the plaintiffs and resin supplier Formosa Plastics Co. USA, which is the former parent company of JM Eagle. Hendrix is entitled to 15-25 percent of the amount recovered.

Formosa admitted no liability and agreed to settle to avoid further legal costs. The settlement also included a separately negotiated $5.5 million payment to compensate Phillips & Cohen for attorney fees and costs.


JM Eagle slaps law firm with libel complaint

By Catherine Kavanaugh
Staff Reporter

Published: February 25, 2014 1:32 pm ET
Updated: February 25, 2014 1:37 pm ET

Post Your Comments

Back to story

More stories


Auto supplier Cooper-Standard to trim operations in Europe

January 22, 2015 11:08 am ET

Novi, Mich.-based Cooper-Sandard Holdings Inc. said Jan. 21 it plans to consolidate its operations in Europe, including reducing manufacturing in...    More


New Vinyl Building Council leader out to build on grassroots efforts

January 20, 2015 12:54 pm ET

As the new executive director of the Vinyl Building Council, Kevin Koonce will oversee advocacy for the most-used plastic in building and...    More


Plastics help create net-zero energy home

January 20, 2015 3:31 pm ET

The New American Home — a working lab of best construction practices since 1984 — has reached its greenest goal yet with plastic pushing...    More


Public utilities appeal latest decision in JM Eagle case

January 20, 2015 1:08 pm ET

The law firm representing public utilities in a False Claims Act lawsuit against J-M Manufacturing Co. — now called JM Eagle — plans to...    More


Mohawk buying IVC Group for $1.2 billion to grow in luxury vinyl tile

January 14, 2015 5:29 pm ET

Mohawk Industries Inc., which bills itself as the world's largest flooring company, is acquiring IVC Group — a rapidly growing manufacturer of l...    More

Market Reports

Plastics in Automotive: Innovation & Emerging Trends

This special report newly released by PN and sponsored by The Conair Group examines current trends in the use of plastics in automotive, materials innovations and the changing landscape. It includes a review of legislative/regulatory activity impacting vehicle development and lightweighting, market opportunities & challenges for mold and toolmakers, innovative design strategies being implemented by major OEMs and suppliers, as well as a review of key indicators in Canada, Mexico, Brazil and China.

Learn more

Plastics Recycling Trends in North America

This report is a review and analysis of the North American Plastics Recycling Industry, including key trends and statistics based on 2013 performance. We examine market environment factors, regulatory issues, industry challenges, key drivers and emerging trends in post-consumer and post-industrial recycling.

Learn more

Injection Molding Market Analysis & Processor Rankings

Plastics News BUNDLED package contains our in-depth Market Analysis of the Injection Molding segment. You will gain keen insight on current trends and our economic outlook.

As a BONUS this includes PN's updated 2014 database of North American Injection Molders RANKED by sales volume. Sort, merge, mail & prospect by end market, materials processed, region, # of plants and more.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

February 4, 2015 - February 6, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

June 2, 2015 - June 3, 2015Plastics Financial Summit - Chicago 2015

September 16, 2015 - September 18, 2015Plastics Caps & Closures - September 2015

More Events