Auto supplier Hi-Lex wins federal court appeal over insurance costs

Chad Halcom
CRAIN'S DETROIT BUSINESS

Published: May 16, 2014 11:05 am ET
Updated: May 16, 2014 11:07 am ET

Related to this story

Topics Public Policy, United States, Automotive

An auto supplier won a federal court appeal over a health insurer in a $6 million dispute over hidden fees charged to self-insured clients.

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Wednesday ruled in favor of Hi-Lex Controls Inc., a Litchfield, Mich.-based maker of window regulators with an automotive design center in suburban Detroit, over Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan.

The company is a subsidiary of Tokyo-based Hi-Lex Corp. and molds cables and regulators for car windows, sun roofs and other systems.

The appellate court in Cincinnati upheld a U.S. District Court judgment last June in favor of the supplier.

The appeals court had sided with U.S. District Judge Victoria Roberts, who found that Blue Cross had used a deceptive practice to hide fees and surcharges that were rolled into claims billed under administrative services contracts with self-insured businesses and local governments.

“(Blue Cross) also gave a misleading response to a request for proposal issued by Hi-Lex by denying that it charged ‘access fees,’” the appellate ruling states. “This response helped sustain the illusion that (the insurer) was more cost-competitive than other (third party administrators) who responded to the (request).”

Administrative services contracts allow self-insured employers, retirement funds, unions and other organizations to use Blue Cross’ network and administrative services to process insurance claims.

Roberts had previously found Blue Cross had concealed four fees in billing statements to Hi-Lex for employee benefit claims — a network access fee, a contribution to the Blues' contingency reserve, a retiree coverage surcharge and an “other-than-group fee” that helped subsidize its Medigap coverage plan for senior citizens.

The insurer has said previously that its Hi-Lex contract language is identical to a similar agreement it maintained for a self-insured county government. That county obtained a $1.14 million judgment in 2011 in its own lawsuit against Blue Cross, but the Michigan Court of Appeals the following year reversed that judgment in the insurer's favor.

“Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan is disappointed in the decision in federal court, which runs contrary to state court rulings over the same contract language,” Blue Cross Director of Corporate Communications Helen Stojic said in a statement.

“We are reviewing the decision for appeal. The access fees under dispute enabled Hi-Lex to receive substantial discounts in hospital services, which resulted in millions of dollars of savings in hospital costs for Hi-Lex.”

“We are very happy that the judgment was affirmed,” said Hi-Lex attorney Perrin Rynders of Grand Rapids, Mich.-based Varnum LLP. “It's been a long time coming, but we never doubted that this would be the ultimate outcome … litigation was not our client's preferred approach, but (the Blues) refused at every turn to accept responsibility for its actions.”

Varnum has brought more than 30 lawsuits in U.S. District Court in Detroit on behalf of various self-insured companies, including Hi-Lex, but the other pending cases were under a stay to await the outcome of Hi-Lex's appeal.


Comments

Auto supplier Hi-Lex wins federal court appeal over insurance costs

Chad Halcom
CRAIN'S DETROIT BUSINESS

Published: May 16, 2014 11:05 am ET
Updated: May 16, 2014 11:07 am ET

Post Your Comments


Back to story


More stories

Image

SPE Thermoforming Division picks 3 scholarship winners

September 16, 2014 4:25 pm ET

Three college students have earned scholarships through the Society of Plastics Engineers' Thermoforming Division, division officials announced at...    More

Image

Canadian, Mexican injection molders form auto supply joint venture

September 16, 2014 2:26 pm ET

A new automotive parts manufacturer will open in Querétaro, Mexico, through a joint venture between Canadian automotive supplier Papp Plastics and...    More

Image

DuPont investing $100 million for more ethylene copolymer capacity

September 16, 2014 1:51 pm ET

Increased packaging demand is leading materials giant DuPont Co. to spend more than $100 million to increase capacity for ethylene copolymers at its...    More

Image

American Renolit sees steady gains in the film market

September 16, 2014 11:51 am ET

American Renolit Corp. has changed its product mix, changed its customer base and managed to grow in a market that was initially skeptical about the...    More

Image

Increased capacity in the US helps Zeon Chemical supply seals globally

September 16, 2014 9:46 am ET

The automotive industry continues to be one of the driving forces of Zeon Chemicals LP., which specializes in heat-resistant and oil-resistant elastom...    More

Market Reports

Shale Gas Market - Analysis of North American Region

This report highlights the impact of shale-based natural gas on the North American plastics market and features an in-depth analysis of production trends in the United States during 2013 and a forecast for 2014 and beyond.

Learn more

Thermoformed Packaging 2014 Market Review & Outlook – North America

This in-depth report analyzes economic and market trends, legislative/regulatory activity impacting supply and demand, business opportunities and threats, materials pricing, manufacturing technology, as well as growth strategies being implemented by thermoformed packaging companies.

Learn more

Pipe, Profile & Tubing Extrusion in North America 2014

U.S. demand for extruded plastics is expected to grow by 3 percent in 2014, with PVC remaining the largest segment.

Plastic pipe will post the strongest gains through 2018, continuing to take market share from competing materials in a range of markets.

Our latest market report provides in-depth analysis of current trends and their financial impact on the pipe, profile and tubing extrusion industry in North America.

Learn more

Upcoming Plastics News Events

January 14, 2015 - January 14, 2015Plastics in Automotive

February 4, 2015 - February 6, 2015Plastics News Executive Forum 2015

More Events