Every once in a while I see critical coverage of plastics from an unexpected place. That happened today, when I spotted a story from the National Catholic Reporter newsweekly that slams the bottled water industry.
The story, by freelance writer Laura Lloyd, pulls together a variety of threads about various religious leaders and groups -- most of them Catholic, of course -- that are "spreading the gospel that bottled water, however convenient to tote around, is environmentally, economically and politically wrong."
Where is the push coming from? According to the story, "Some Catholic groups have borrowed information and ideas from Think Outside the Bottle, a major non-religious player in the anti-bottled water movement. The organization has launched a Web-based campaign that provides information and support. In addition to inviting individuals to sign a pledge to boycott bottled water, the program urges people to send postcards to corporations challenging corporate control of water, to attend stockholders’ meetings and mount other forms of pressure on corporate executives. Think Outside the Bottle (www.thinkoutsidethebottle.org) is part of a larger organization called Corporate Accountability International (www.stopcorporateabuse.org)."
The church has a long history of activism, often on environmental issues. Still, it's a bit surprising to see this so many religious leaders taking a stand against bottled water. It will be interesting to see how many parishioners listen to the message.



Comments (1)
Sad how both misinformed and misguided my church and many groups are aboput such issues . Kim Jeffrey of Nestle Great Waters , N.A. is a very articulate advocate for both bottled water and plastic packaging. He calmly explains how these groups neatly skip over plastic bottled carbonated soda ( hello .........adolescent obesity crisis ) and many other plastic bottled beverages . So is the problem water or PET?
These are complex vital issues which need well advised spokespersons and well thought out positions .
The dialog must consider alternatives and lesser of evils realistic consumption options. On-the-go consumers aren't going to buy water by the glass .......so let's focus on reducing the resin options , recycling viability, source reduction, thin-walling (Nestle GWNA is doing AMAZING things ). Hysteria on the side of the "greenies" is not the answer , even if they are Catholics!
Posted by Hoop Roche | January 9, 2008 9:47 AM
Posted on January 9, 2008 09:47