About The Plastics Blog
As managing editor of Plastics News, I scan scores of Web sites, emails and news releases daily, and stay in constant touch with our network of global staff reporters and correspondents -- the largest reporting team in the plastics industry. I distill the more interesting items into commentary for this blog. Plastics News, part of Crain Communications Inc., began publishing weekly news in 1989, and launched a bilingual China site in mid-2005. In 2007, Crain acquired the two leading English-language plastics publications in Europe - Plastics & Rubber Weekly and the monthly European Plastics News.
Search this blog
Calendar: September 2009
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30      
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
  • Peter Gardner: Regarding the FDA statement: What really must be considered, is read more
  • David Yopak: This kind of stuff is only fuel for the NGOs. read more
Archive Categories
Monthly Archives

Who to believe, FDA or NTP?

| 2 Comments | No TrackBacks

Here's government in action... today the National Toxicology Program released a statement and a report that suggests that parents might want to reduce infants' exposure to products containing bisphenol A, such as polycarbonate baby bottles.

Remember, this comes just a few months after the Food and Drug Administration took the opposite approach, with testimony to Congress that BPA is safe.

When FDA came out with its statement, I was surprised by the amount of press converage it generated. After all, FDA wasn't really saying anything new -- the agency has said all along that BPA is safe.

Now the National Toxicology Program is publicly contradicting FDA. Here's NTP's advice to parents:

More research is clearly needed to understand exactly how these findings relate to human health and development, but at this point we can't dismiss the possibility that the effects we're seeing in animals may occur in humans. If parents are concerned, they can make the personal choice to reduce exposures of their infants and children to BPA.

With the release of this report, you can expect to see BPA in the mainstream media again, like this story posted today from USA Today.

And expect to see a lot of very confused consumers.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.plasticsnews.com/mt-tb.cgi/2522

Comments (2)

David Yopak:

This kind of stuff is only fuel for the NGOs.

Regarding the FDA statement: What really must be considered, is the CUMULATIVE EFFECT of exposures to all various chemicals, pesticides, etc. Although each individual study might conclude that exposure levels are "acceptable", these studies do not consider the barrage of chemicals and pollutants that we are exposed to on a daily basis...

Regarding the NTP statement, it would be wise to consider that the negative effects seen in animals, surely may also occur in humans...to think that humans , who are made up of the same raw materials as animals, are somehow immune to the negative effects already shown in these animals, would be quite foolish.

Is it really a big deal to take the BPA out of the products, as many manufacturers are now starting to do?

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)



SITE INDEX
Home: PN.com | Contact editorial | Contact advertising | Century of Plastics | NPE 2009 | About us
Resin Pricing: All resins | Commodity TPs | High-temp TPs | ETPs | Thermosets | Recycled plastics | LME North America | LME Asia | LME Europe | LME global contracts
Rankings/Lists: All | Injection molders | Blow molders | Film & sheet | Thermoformers | Pipe/profile/tubing | Rotomolders | Mold/toolmakers | Executive pay | Recyclers | Plastic lumber | Compounders | Associations
More News From Crain
Automotive News
BtoB
European Rubber Journal
Rubber & Plastics News
Urethanes Technology International
Waste & Recycling News
Workforce Management
List of all Crain publications
End Markets: Automotive | Packaging | Construction | Medical | Consumer products | Sustainability | Public Policy
Processor News: Injection molding | Blow molding | Film & sheet | Pipe/profile/tubing | Rotomolding | Thermoforming | Recycling
Supplier News: Machinery | Materials | Molds/tooling | Product news | Design
Opinion: The Plastics Blog | The China Blog | Viewpoint | Perspective | Mailbag
FYI Charts: Current FYI | Automotive | Packaging | Machinery | Materials | Molds/tooling | Recycling | Processors | Miscellaneous
Directory: Online directory | Plastics processors | Primary equipment suppliers | Auxiliary equipment | Materials suppliers | Plastics industry services
Classifieds: View Classifieds ads | Place a Classified ad
Multimedia: Video | Audio clips | Slide shows
Our Events: Executive Forum 2010 | Medical Devices 2010 | PRW/EPN | Encounters
Industry Events
Awards: Processor of the Year
Advertising: In Print | Classified | Online
Subscribe: Print | Online | E-mail products
Reprints
List Rental: Print | Online
Resin Selector

Entire contents copyright 2010 by Crain Communications Inc.
All rights reserved. | Terms & Conditions | Plastics News Business Directory | Privacy policy | Technical Information
For information about this web site contact webmaster@plasticsnews.com