SEARCH

ABOUT
This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on May 16, 2008 10:32 AM.

The previous post in this blog was China's 1st bottle reclaim machine.

The next post in this blog is Grace note: China tightens visa rules.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by Movable Type 3.34





Return to The PN China Blog home page
Go to the PlasticsNews.com/China home page

« China's 1st bottle reclaim machine | Main | Grace note: China tightens visa rules »

Hands-on due diligence in China

"More than half of factories in southern China are falsifying payroll documents!"

"Many even create Potemkin factories.... Around the corner is a 'shadow factory' that produces the same goods under much less wholesome conditions."

"There is even a cottage industry of 'falsification engineers' in China--consultants who specialize in doctoring payroll records and coaching workers to create a fiction of compliance with a Western buyer's code of conduct."

The above statements are from Alexandra Harney's latest viewpoint for Plastics News' sister publication AdAgeChina, How to work with Chinese factories without getting burned(registration required). She is a China-based journalist and author.

What's more sensational than the bold statements about unethical business practices in China, is her suggestion that, instead of waiting for Beijing to improve law enforcement, Western multinationals can be a large part of the solution to the problems--whose consequences include costly product recalls, falsified documents and worsening pollution.

Here are the steps Harney suggested taking:


1. Acknowledge that understanding what's happening in the company's supply chain is not simply a matter of risk management or good corporate citizenship; it is a core business issue and a valuable competitive advantage.
2. Build frank, long-term partnerships with Chinese factories, rather than moving orders quickly from one plant to another.
3. Take a field trip at least once or twice a year.


But the most interesting advice was:

Schedule a visit to one of your suppliers, but arrive quietly the night before your appointment, perhaps with a Chinese colleague. Instead of having dinner at the hotel restaurant, eat near your factory and spend time with the locals. Ask them: What's the average monthly wage in this area? Are wages going up or down? What time do most people get off work? What is considered the best factory to work for, and why? Have there been any problems in any of the factories recently, fights or disagreements?


Ask motorcycle drivers that work near your supplier about the hours your factory keeps its lights on, and whether they see a lot of traffic between your supplier and others in the neighborhood.
When you meet the factory manager the next day, ask him the same questions and compare his answers to what you learned the night before.

Sounds like some good advice from a real China expert. However, don't assume the locals and motorcycle drivers -- if there are any -- really know the answers to your questions, even if they provide you with information. Be aware that Chinese Culture 101 dictates that, out of politeness, Chinese people won't tell you no. If the motorcycle driver isn't sure about the hours of the factory, he will probably give you an answer anyway, just to complete the conversation nicely.

So, like any due diligence work, talk to multiple sources with different backgrounds and interests.

TRACKBACK

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.plasticsnews.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/571

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hands-on due diligence in China:

» How To Monitor Your Chinese Factory, The China Price, And QC By Motorcycle. from China Law Blog
Interesting post by Nina Ying Sun on the PN [Plastics News] China blog on the inherent difficulties inherent of monitoring your China factory. The post is entitled "Hands-on due diligence in China," and it starts out with the following quotes from an i... [Read More]

Tracked on May 22, 2008 2:46 PM
COMMENTS (1)
Bharath Srinivasan:

Observations of Alexandra Harney reflects the limited understanding of people from much smaller (in terms of population), advanced economies on the issues of governance and labor market dynamics in much larger (in terms of population) economies.

Does that mean people can be exploited? Certainly not. In a country of 1.3 billion with may be 600 million workforce, how is it possible to meet the developed country work standards and still leave the labor - market oriented? Does it mean that US had the best of worker practices all along in the 230 years of development if you start from 1776?

China is just developing for 30 years and has may be 10 times more workforce to handle. The best solution for this is to empower a small labor group within the company to highlight any excesses. Nobody would venture into this solution as this could be akin to the catching the tiger by its tail.

If you are a buyer from China, and are really concerned about the welfare of the worker in China (not worried about the embarrassment your company will face if the condition of the workforce is exposed aka GE in Shantou); then take majority stake in a company and enforce the rules of the game.

The advantage that one sees in China Labor Market is only on account of this surplus workforce. From what I see in the factories here, the conditions are far far better than in some other developing economies like India where the labor force empowerment is sometime beyond any management's comfort zone.

POST A COMMENT
(Your comment needs to be approved by the site owner before appearing. Thanks for waiting.)