With concerns mounting over how to contain coronavirus in the U.S., lawmakers in Maine voted March 17 to delay implementation of their plastic bag ban until next year.
The decision, part of large package of emergency pandemic measures in that state, comes as a few elected officials around the country are pushing to delay or halt other single-use plastics bans, arguing that reusables pose more risk of spreading the virus.
Maine's single-use plastic bag ban had been set to start April 22, but Gov. Janet Mills, a Democrat, announced a series of actions March 17 that included delaying the ban until January 15, 2021. The law also requires retailers to charge a fee of 5 cents on recycled paper or reusable plastic bags.
"These emergency measures will support the state's response to the coronavirus and mitigate its spread in Maine," Mills said.
Maine's decision comes as some large corporations like Starbucks have taken steps to temporarily halt accepting reusable containers from customers over hygiene concerns.
It's too soon to say if Maine's actions would be followed by other states. A few state legislatures, including Maryland and Washington state, had been moving ahead on plastic bag bans in recent days.
Washington's legislature passed a plastic bag ban and an 8 cent fee on paper bags on March 10. In Maryland, lawmakers in the state's house adopted a plastic bag ban March 12.
But as the virus has spread, political figures in other states have been pushing action similar to Maine's.
In New York, the top Republican in the state Senate urged the legislature on March 10 to suspend the plastic bag ban that went into effect March 1.
"It is time to protect New Yorkers from the continuing spread of coronavirus by taking the additional steps of suspending the plastic bag ban and saying no to policies — at this time — that could lead to any additional cases," said Republican Sen. John Flanagan, minority leader of the Senate, in a statement.
He said New York has among the highest number of coronavirus cases in the U.S. and criticized Democrats, who control the chamber, for advancing other bills in committee that call for more reusable containers. Enforcement of New York's bag ban has been delayed until April 1, pending a legal challenge unrelated to the virus.
A handful of cities are also phasing back single-use plastics bans or discussing it.
Brookline, Mass., for example, announced March 16 that it was suspending its ban on expanded polystyrene containers to ease the burden on restaurants, after the town banned all dine-in service in eateries.
As well, the mayor of the small town of Waterville, Maine, urged the city March 15 to temporarily suspend a ban on plastic bags it passed last year, as well encourage retailers to ban shoppers from using bags brought from home.
"These reusable tote bags can sustain the COVID-19 and flu viruses — and spread the viruses throughout the store," said Mayor Nick Isgro, on his Facebook page. "Be assured this is not to re-litigate our current ordinance. … This should be seen as a temporary public safety measure."
Matt Seaholm, executive director of the American Recyclable Plastic Bag Alliance in Washington, said bag ban suspensions are good for public health.
"It's increasingly evident that plastic bags are indispensable in helping citizens get the food and goods they need and preventing the transmission of germs, bacteria and viruses," he said. "There is ample scientific research concluding reusable bags can contribute to the spread of bacteria and viruses, and now more than ever state and local governments need to take every step possible to ensure people of are safe and healthy."
But organizations advocating for reusable packaging say properly washed reusables are as safe as disposables.
The Rockport, Maine-based group Upstream said in a March 17 statement that single-use disposables can also harbor viruses and pathogenic bacteria acquired along the supply chain, and it said the crisis points to the need for stronger reusable systems.
"In parts of the world, companies have already developed reusable to-go services for take-out and food delivery," Upstream said. "These businesses provide clean, sanitized reusable cups and to-go containers to restaurants and cafes."
It said that Starbucks and other businesses "are rightly focused on how to keep us all safe. But when the coronavirus passes, plastic pollution will continue to be a huge environmental problem."